Maine State Representative Erik C. Jorgensen
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Issues
  • Legislation
  • Occasional Blog
  • Where in Deering?
  • Contact
  • Sec of State

Why I did not support the Dakota Access Pipeline Bill

10/27/2017

2 Comments

 
Having been called out by the Maine People's Alliance for voting against the so-called "Dakota Access Pipeline Divestiture Bill" I wanted to share my reasoning for this position. The bill would have instructed the State of Maine to divest from deposits in any bank that has helped to finance the Dakota Access Pipeline. This would have fallen most heavily on the State Retirement system.

I need to be crystal clear that I am no friend of the Dakota Access pipeline. That project is is an outrageous abridgment of tribal sovereignty and I think that the issue of risk to clean water has been vastly whitewashed by the proponents of the project. 

So I support the issue very much. But I didn't support that bill.

My primary reason for opposing that bill was a simple one: The purpose of the Maine State retirement system is to provide return for retirees who do not qualify to receive social security and who have trusted their lifetime pensions to that fund. It's not the state's money - it is all owed to the individuals who paid into it.  Therefore I oppose any sort of restrictions on its investments  for specific political causes (however valid those causes are) unless the people who own the funds have voted that whatever restriction is being proposed is okay with them. 

It's difficult, because this year it's DAPL - two years ago, it was a proposed plan to force the fund to divest from all fossil fuels. I could think of many other things that I would like us not to invest in, like Monsanto, or various drug companies that in my estimation fleece the American people, or, for that matter, Wal-Mart.  Another bill this session, from right-wing activists, would have forced us to stop any investments or business with any company that has boycotted Israel. We killed that, too, thankfully.

The difficulty with these issues is that if you start placing legal restrictions on investment options, you quickly end up with a whole grid of restrictions that makes investing harder, and puts Maine retirees at a relative disadvantage.  Many of those retirees already have pensions that leave them in poverty because they were paid poorly during their working careers, and I am troubled by that. 

Oil is something that every single American uses every single day of every year, either directly or indirectly. It would be very hard to single out specific DAPL investments in companies in that sector and in the financial services sector, which is so interlinked with the whole US economy.  This particular bill was very vague in how it defined investment in DAPL, and I think that even if I was able to ignore the issues above, I would have opposed it for that more technical reason.  

Finally, I think it's worth noting that the Maine Retirement system already takes into account environmental and social considerations when it makes its investments.  I don't know if the fund actually holds any specific assets that were directly tied to the DAPL project, but if there were serious concerns about a specific company, those factors would be considered by the fund as part of that process.   The legislature is not equipped to make investment decisions, and that's why we have people whose sole job is to consider all these issues in managing the billions of Maine State Workers' dollars that they've been entrusted with. 

I don't know if you are moved by these arguments, but I hope I can offer at least a glimpse into my reasoning.  This was neither a reflexive nor an idealogical vote for me.  As much as I support those who object to DAPL I had no problem saying no to this idea.  

2 Comments
customized writes helpers of the best quality link
2/19/2018 09:25:40 am

this is a personal choice of everyone, thank you for sharing your opinion, it is very important for us to know your opinion

Reply
writers link
4/9/2018 03:02:30 pm

The system is new and can be easily used for this project. Have a nice day.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Picture

    Author

    Erik C. Jorgensen represents Maine House District 41 - Part of Portland. This blog represents his own opinions and not those of the Maine Legislature, Maine Democrats, or anyone else. To read more about me, click here

    Archives

    April 2020
    March 2019
    July 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    December 2016
    September 2016
    May 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    June 2013
    February 2013
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    May 2012

    Categories

    All
    126th Legislature
    Angus King
    Baseball
    Bicycle Coalition Of Maine
    Bicycles
    Birds
    Blueberries
    Bonus Depreciation
    Campaign
    Casco Bay High School
    Cat Food
    Courts
    Dakota Access Pipeline
    Difficult Votes
    Electric Cars
    Endorsements
    Energy Mix Solar
    Environment
    General Assistance
    Governor LePage
    Hair Braiding
    Health Care Cost
    Help Fix Me Program
    Hospitals
    Hybrids
    Hydro Power
    Immigrants And Asylum Seekers
    Independent Transportation Network
    Judicial Branch
    League Of Young Voters
    Maine
    Maine Care Expansion
    Maine Conservation Voters
    Maine State Retirement System
    Marriage Equality
    Mayor Brennan
    New Brunswick
    Paul R. LePage
    Portland Business Development
    Portland Community Health Center
    Portland Harbor
    Portland Maine
    Portland Maine
    Project Bazia
    Quebec
    Renewable
    Rep Daughtry
    Rep Jorgensen
    Rep Jorgensen
    Rep. Kruger
    Rep. Richard Farnsworth
    Revenue Sharing
    Riverview Psychiatric Center
    Ryan Reid / Ryan Flaherty
    Senator Gratwick
    Senator Haskell
    Speaker Mark Eves
    Speaker Mark Eves
    Student Debt
    Supplemental Budget
    Tax Conformity
    Transportation
    Voter Education Brigade
    Wildlife
    Zinke

All pages Authorized and © 2012-2020 by The Committee to Elect Erik Jorgensen, 83 Highland Street Portland Maine 04103
​